| 1ST Bro. H.I. Fontello Nanton | 1940 | Phi Lambda |
| 2nd Bro. John P. Bond | 1942 | Phi Lambda |
| 3rd Bro. Noah Harold Bennett, Jr. | ?-1954 | Beta Theta Lambda |
| 4th Bro. Leroy Benjamin Fraiser | 1955-57 | Beta Theta Lambda |
| 5th Bro. Noah Harold Bennett, Jr. | 1957-61 | Beta Theta Lambda |
| 6th Bro. Arthur John Howard Clement III | 1961-64 | Beta Theta Lambda |
| 7th Bro. George Henry Vaughn | 1964-66 | Alpha Pi Lambda |
| 8th Bro. Arthur John Howard Clement III | 1966-68 | Beta Theta Lambda |
| 9th Bro. Leonard Ross Ballou | 1968-69 | Epsilon Chi Lambda |
| 10th Bro. Johnnie Edward Burke | 1969-71 | Phi Lambda |
| 11th Bro. Willie L. Bryant | 1971 | Phi Lambda |
| 12th Bro. Walter Wade Sullivan | 1971-73 | Kappa Lambda |
| 13th Bro. Augustus McIver Witherspoon | 1973-82 | Phi Lambda |
| 14th Bro. Amos Rudolph Hendricks IV | 1982-85 | Beta Nu Lambda |
| 15th Bro. Jerome Coleman | 1985-87 | Beta Theta Lambda |
| 16th Bro. Roger Allen McLean | 1987-90 | Epsilon Chi Lambda |
| 17th Bro. Willis Edwyn Baird | 1990-95 | Beta Theta Lambda |
| 18th Bro. Raymond Clayton Perry | 1995-2000 | Phi Lambda |
| 19th Bro. Orlando Elwood Hankins, Sr. | 2000-2004 | Phi Lambda |
| 20th Bro. Craig Francis Reed | 2004-2008 | Rho Alpha Lambda |
| 21st Bro. Laurence Keyth Aikens | 2008-2012 | Kappa Lambda |
| 22nd Bro. Carl Pickney | 2012-2016 | Beta Theta Lambda |
| 23rd Bro. Tejuan Manners | 2016-2020 | Phi Lambda |
| 24th Bro. Michael Pittman | 2020- | Kappa Lambda |